Antibiotic Comparison Tool
Find the Best Antibiotic for Your Situation
Answer these quick questions to see which antibiotic might be most appropriate for your specific infection.
Recommended Options
When you’re prescribed Augmentin for a stubborn infection, you might wonder: Is there something better? Or cheaper? Or safer? You’re not alone. Augmentin - a mix of amoxicillin and clavulanate - is one of the most common antibiotics doctors hand out for sinus infections, ear infections, pneumonia, and skin bugs. But it’s not the only option. And sometimes, it’s not even the best one for your situation.
What is Augmentin, really?
Augmentin isn’t just amoxicillin with a fancy name. It’s amoxicillin + clavulanate. Clavulanate is the secret sauce. It blocks the enzymes that some bacteria use to break down amoxicillin. That means Augmentin can kill bugs that plain amoxicillin can’t touch. Think of it like a lock and key: amoxicillin is the key, but some bacteria have a lock that jams the key. Clavulanate picks that jam, letting the key turn.
It’s effective against common offenders like Staphylococcus aureus, H. influenzae, and Moraxella catarrhalis. But it doesn’t work on everything. Viral infections? Nope. MRSA? Usually not. And it’s not first-line for urinary tract infections unless there’s a known resistant strain.
Side effects? Up to 1 in 10 people get diarrhea, nausea, or a rash. Some get yeast infections. It’s not dangerous for most, but it’s not gentle either.
Why look at alternatives?
There are three big reasons people ask about other options:
- Cost - Augmentin can cost $60-$120 for a full course in the U.S., even with insurance. In Australia, it’s cheaper but still not budget-friendly.
- Side effects - If you got sick from Augmentin before, you want to avoid it again.
- Resistance - Overuse has made some bacteria immune to it. If your infection isn’t improving, it might be resistant.
Here’s what you should know: not every infection needs antibiotics. Many sinus and ear infections clear on their own. But if your doctor says you need one, here are the most common alternatives.
Amoxicillin alone - the simpler cousin
Amoxicillin without clavulanate is cheaper, gentler, and just as effective for many infections. The CDC says for uncomplicated ear infections in kids, amoxicillin alone works just as well as Augmentin. Same for many mild sinus infections.
Why use it? If your infection is likely caused by bacteria that don’t produce the enzyme that breaks down amoxicillin - like Streptococcus pneumoniae - then you don’t need the extra punch.
Downside? It fails if the bug is resistant. That’s why doctors often start with amoxicillin first. If it doesn’t work in 48-72 hours, they switch to Augmentin.
Doxycycline - for when you need something broader
Doxycycline is a tetracycline antibiotic. It’s not a penicillin, so it’s safe if you’re allergic to amoxicillin. It’s often used for:
- Acne (long-term, low dose)
- Lyme disease
- Sinus infections in adults with penicillin allergies
- Some skin infections
It’s also active against atypical bacteria like Mycoplasma and Chlamydia, which amoxicillin can’t touch. That’s why it’s sometimes used for persistent coughs or bronchitis that don’t respond to penicillins.
Downsides? It can make your skin super sensitive to sunlight. You need to take it on an empty stomach. And it’s not for kids under 8 or pregnant women - it stains developing teeth.
Cephalexin - the cephalosporin option
Cephalexin (Keflex) is a first-generation cephalosporin. It’s often used for skin infections like cellulitis, or for ear infections when amoxicillin fails. It’s similar to amoxicillin in spectrum but more stable against some enzymes.
It’s a good alternative if you’re allergic to penicillin - but only if the allergy isn’t severe. About 10% of people allergic to penicillin also react to cephalosporins. So if you broke out in hives or had trouble breathing with amoxicillin, talk to your doctor before trying this.
Side effects are mild: stomach upset, occasional diarrhea. It’s not as strong as Augmentin against Staphylococcus that makes beta-lactamase, but it’s fine for most community infections.
Azithromycin - the ‘Z-Pack’
Azithromycin is a macrolide. You’ve probably heard of the ‘Z-Pack’ - five days of pills, often just one per day. It’s popular because it’s convenient.
It’s used for:
- Respiratory infections (bronchitis, pneumonia)
- Sinus infections (if other antibiotics failed)
- Whooping cough
- Some skin infections
It’s not as strong as Augmentin for ear infections in kids, but it’s better tolerated. No stomach upset? Great. But it’s not great for all bugs. It doesn’t cover Streptococcus pneumoniae as reliably as amoxicillin.
Biggest risk? Heart rhythm issues in people with existing heart conditions. The FDA issued a warning in 2013. If you have a history of irregular heartbeat, this isn’t your first pick.
Trimethoprim-sulfamethoxazole - the backup for resistant bugs
Known as Bactrim or Septra, this combo fights a wide range of bacteria. It’s often used for:
- Urinary tract infections
- Some skin infections
- Traveler’s diarrhea
- MRSA skin infections (in some cases)
It’s not a go-to for sinus or ear infections, but if you’ve tried Augmentin and it didn’t work, this might be next. It’s also cheaper than Augmentin in many places.
Downsides? Can cause severe rashes, especially in older adults or people with HIV. Also, it can lower your blood cell counts. You need blood tests if you’re on it long-term.
When to stick with Augmentin
Augmentin still wins in three cases:
- You have a confirmed infection from a beta-lactamase-producing bacteria - like some strains of Staph or H. influenzae.
- You’re a child with a recurrent ear infection that didn’t respond to plain amoxicillin.
- Your doctor has a culture showing resistance to simpler antibiotics.
It’s also the most studied option for these infections. There’s decades of data backing it. Alternatives might work, but we know Augmentin works - and we know how to manage its side effects.
What about natural remedies or herbal options?
You’ll see ads for garlic, honey, or oregano oil as ‘natural antibiotics.’ Some studies show mild antibacterial effects in labs. But none have been proven to treat a real, active bacterial infection in humans like a prescription antibiotic does.
Using them instead of antibiotics can turn a simple ear infection into a ruptured eardrum. Or a sinus infection into a brain abscess. That’s not bravery - it’s dangerous.
Herbs can help with symptoms - honey for cough, saltwater rinse for sinuses - but they don’t kill bacteria the way antibiotics do. Don’t trade science for slogans.
How to choose the right one for you
There’s no universal ‘best’ antibiotic. The right one depends on:
- Your age - Kids get different options than adults.
- Your allergies - Penicillin allergy? Avoid amoxicillin and Augmentin.
- Where the infection is - Ear? Sinus? Skin? UTI? Each has preferred drugs.
- How sick you are - Mild? Try amoxicillin first. Severe? Augmentin or something stronger.
- What you’ve tried before - If you got diarrhea from Augmentin last time, avoid it again.
Ask your doctor: ‘Is this infection likely to be caused by a bug that responds to amoxicillin alone? Or do we need the clavulanate?’ That’s the key question.
What if Augmentin didn’t work?
If you took Augmentin for 3-4 days and feel worse - or no better - call your doctor. Don’t just keep taking it. You might need:
- A different antibiotic
- A culture test to find the exact bug
- A referral to an infectious disease specialist
Antibiotic failure is common. It doesn’t mean you’re ‘resistant’ - it means the bug might be something else, or you need a different dose or route (like an injection instead of a pill).
Final thoughts: Don’t guess. Ask.
There’s no magic bullet. Augmentin is powerful, but it’s not always necessary. Amoxicillin alone works more often than people think. Doxycycline or cephalexin might be better if you’re allergic. Azithromycin is convenient. Bactrim is cheap and broad.
The best choice isn’t the one you read about online. It’s the one your doctor picks based on your body, your history, and your infection - not a YouTube video or a Reddit thread.
If you’re unsure, ask: ‘What’s the most targeted, least risky option here?’ That’s the question that leads to the right answer.
Is Augmentin stronger than amoxicillin?
Yes, but only against certain bacteria. Augmentin includes clavulanate, which blocks enzymes that some bacteria use to resist amoxicillin. So it works on bugs that plain amoxicillin can’t. For infections caused by simple strep or pneumococcus, amoxicillin alone is just as effective.
Can I switch from Augmentin to amoxicillin?
Only if your doctor says so. If your infection is mild and likely caused by a bacteria that doesn’t produce resistance enzymes, amoxicillin may be enough. But if you’re not improving, switching down could make things worse. Never change antibiotics without medical advice.
What’s the cheapest alternative to Augmentin?
Amoxicillin alone is usually the cheapest option. In Australia, a 10-day course of amoxicillin can cost under $10 with a prescription. Trimethoprim-sulfamethoxazole (Bactrim) is also low-cost and often used for UTIs or skin infections when Augmentin isn’t needed.
Are there natural alternatives to Augmentin?
No. Honey, garlic, or essential oils may soothe symptoms, but none can reliably kill the bacteria causing a serious infection like pneumonia, sinusitis, or cellulitis. Relying on them instead of antibiotics can lead to complications, hospitalization, or even death.
How do I know if my infection is resistant to Augmentin?
If you’ve taken Augmentin for 3-4 days and feel worse - or still have fever, pain, or swelling - it may be resistant. Your doctor may order a culture to identify the exact bacteria and test which antibiotics it responds to. Don’t assume resistance - get it checked.
If you’ve had a bad reaction to Augmentin before, keep a list of what didn’t work - and what did. That info helps your doctor pick the next option faster. Antibiotics are powerful tools, but they’re not one-size-fits-all. The right choice depends on you - not the label.
